Mundell & Associates, Inc.

Consulting Professionals for the Earth and the Environment

  • Careers
  • Hablamos Español
call us at (317) 630-9060
110 S. Downey Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46219 | Fax: (317) 630-9065
  •  
  • Company
    • About Us
    • Our Staff
    • Mission and Vision
    • Social Mission
    • Hablamos Español
    • Careers
    • Contact
  • Services
  • Industry Solutions
  • Portfolio
  • News
Discuss your projectall news
You are here: Home / Portfolio / Variation in Hydraulic Conductivity and Retardation Factor and its Effect on Numerical and Analytical Model Results

Variation in Hydraulic Conductivity and Retardation Factor and its Effect on Numerical and Analytical Model Results

portfolio typeCase Historiespdf iconDownload this as PDFPosted on June 24, 2015

Impacted Groundwater Plume

Challenge

The project Site is the former CS & T Dry Cleaner located on the northeast side of Columbus, Indiana. Soil and groundwater contaminated with Perchloroethene (PCE) was discovered at the Site during a Phase I Investigation performed in 2002. Initial remediation activities using in-situ chemical oxidation were successful in removing a significant portion of the source area of the impacted groundwater plume. However, a significant dissolved plume of organic chemicals remained associated with the Site. In an effort to bring the remedial efforts to an effective closure, Mundell was retained by a partnering consulting firm to evaluate the stability of the dissolved organic plume using groundwater flow and chemical transport modeling. Modeling activities were completed in 2007 utilizing published three-dimensional analytical transport solutions (Domenico and Robbins, 1985; Domenico, 1987) to model the transport of residual contamination in the plume. Using these calibrated results, a comparison between the computer software BIOCHLOR and the utilized 3D analytical transport solution was conducted. Numerous sets of simulations were completed using both modeling methods to determine if they yield comparable results using the same hydraulic inputs. In addition, attempts were made to duplicate the calibrated analytical model results varying solely hydraulic conductivity and the retardation factor (r-factor) within the BIOCHLOR solution.

Action

Upon formulation of a calibrated 3D analytical flow model, identical hydraulic values were utilized in BIOCHLOR to predict center-line concentrations with increasing distance from the source area. Comparison between the simulated PCE concentrations (3D analytical and BIOCHLOR) and the observed PCE concentrations indicated that the fit of the 3D analytical model values to the observed PCE values is significantly better than that of the BIOCHLOR results.

variation-hydraulic-conductivity-1st-simulation

The second set of simulations used identical input parameters as both the previously run 3D analytical and BIOCHLOR simulations with the EXCEPTION of the hydraulic conductivity and r-factor. Attempts were made to set the K value at a more reasonable level (140 ft/d vs. 9 ft/d) and then adjust the r-factor until results similar to the first BIOCHLOR runs were attained.

variation-hydraulic-conductivity-2nd-simulations

As displayed above, several calibration points had multiple r-factor/K combinations that produced PCE concentrations similar to those calculated in the first BIOCHLOR simulations. Unfortunately, variation of the r-factor within a single transport model is not realistic, nor is it supported in either the 3D analytical model or in the BIOCHLOR spreadsheet. Averaging the secondary r-factors to create a single representative value was attempted and input into BIOCHLOR (R = 3.31). Use of this averaged r-factor did not duplicate the earlier BIOCHLOR results, and produced error values in excess of 43%.

An additional attempt to obtain a secondary r-factor was completed by comparing BIOCHLOR simulated PCE concentrations to PCE concentrations observed in the field.

variation-hydraulic-conductivity-3rd-simulations

As in the previous analysis, no single r-factor was attained that consistently reproduced similar results to the initial r-factor/K combination, with error values again extending above 40%.

Results

Examination of both BIOCHLOR simulations showed similar error values when using the secondary r-factor values. However, the difference between the BIOCHLOR simulation errors and the 3D analytical solution errors are significantly different (an order of magnitude or more) and support the use of the 3D analytical solution as the best predicative method for the Site.

Based on these variations, it does not appear that multiple unique solutions can be attained for a single model solely by adjusting the K and r-factor.

more information Learn about our related services (Modeling) and industry solutions (Dry Cleaning)

Similar Portfolio Items

  • Advanced Monitoring/Modeling of Surface-Aquifer Interactions of a Levee System and Infrastructure Design Implications
  • Calibrating Artificial Intelligence and Hydrologic Modeling with Smart Monitoring Inputs for Enhanced Levee Safety Predictions under Changing Climate Conditions
  • Corrective Action Plan and Remediation Planning at a Former Dry Cleaner

Discuss your projectall news

all portfolio View entire portfolio

Portfolio Filter

  • Reset All

Text Search

News

Phase II Environmental Testing Completed through a Collaborative Effort between Delaware County and Local Citizens

April 3, 2023in Science and Environment

Regional Levee Project Presented at AEG Annual Meeting during Dams and Levees Symposium

October 7, 2022in Company News

New IDEM Recycling and Waste Diversion Grants Announced

July 8, 2022in Company News

Karst, Cake, and Indiana Geology

April 22, 2022in Science and Environment

Our Affiliations

- Midwestern States Environmental Consultants Association
- Environmental & Engineering Geophysical Society
- Professional Geologists of Indiana, Inc.
- National Ground Water Association
- American Societies of Chemical / Civil Engineers Engineers without Borders
- Association of Environmental and Engineering Geologists
- Indiana Association for Environmental Professionals
- Geological Society of American
- Indiana Circular Economy Initiative
- Economy of Communion
- Indiana Recycling Coalition

.....and more more affiliations

Be Inspired

Loading...
Download calendarGet full calendar ICAL· Google Calendar

Consume with Care

Discover an alternative to using traditional wrapping paper for birthday gifts – like scarves, old newspapers or discarded maps or magazines.

Vanish energy vampires— appliances that suck energy even when not being used – by unplugging them or using power strips.

Source: UNEP

.....see all tips more tips

Copyright © 2023 · Mundell & Associates, Inc. · 110 S. Downey Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46219 · (317) 630-9060 · Privacy Policy · Terms of Use · Sitemap